Letters from Santa

Due to high demand,

we’re finally offering Letters from Santa!

Customized letters for your kids.
A perfect gift this Christmas

Order a Letter from Santa

When a Child Asks Santa for Something You Can’t Give

On the way home from seeing Santa, your child starts picking names for the puppy they just asked him to bring. When a child asks Santa for something you can’t give, the kindest answer is to show you heard the wish and say what they can expect. “You’d love a puppy. We aren’t getting a dog for Christmas” gives them both pieces in two sentences.

Our personalized Letters from Santa give Santa something else to write about, like the dog books your child checks out every week or the first story they read by themselves. Use the words below to answer the wish at home. Then give Santa a detail your child will recognize when they open their letter.

What to Say First When a Child Asks Santa for Something You Can’t Give

Start with the part your child cares about. If they’ve been drawing a dog bed beside their own bed, say, “You’ve thought a lot about what it would be like to have a dog.” The Child Mind Institute’s guide to disappointment advises listening and acknowledging how a child feels before trying to fix the situation.

If your child expects the gift to arrive, give them a clear answer before Christmas. At the kitchen table or on the ride home, say what you’ve decided in words they understand. “We aren’t getting a pony this Christmas” gives them a clear answer. “We’ll see” leaves the question open.

You can still ask what they like about the wish. A child who wants a puppy might want a pet to cuddle. Another might want a dog they can teach to fetch. What they tell you can help you pick a small gift or plan an afternoon together. If they’re still upset, give them time before asking for another idea.

If They Want a Puppy, a Kitten, or a Pony

If your child asked Santa for a puppy, talk about who would care for it on an ordinary school day. Feeding, walks, and vet visits will still happen after the tree comes down.

The ASPCA’s guidance on pets as gifts calls for lasting interest and the ability to care for the animal. For children under 12, parents should be ready and willing to take responsibility.

The American Academy of Pediatrics’ family pet guide also asks families to consider a child’s maturity and the time an animal needs.

“I can see why you picked a puppy. The grown-ups at home decide when your family is ready to care for a dog. I’m glad you told me what you love about them.”

That’s a line you can write in a short note from Santa after you’ve given your child the answer at home. For a pony wish, a horse book or an afternoon at a stable can honor the interest. If you’re open to a bigger commitment, Horse Network suggests lessons or camp as ways to spend time with horses.

If They Want a Baby Brother or Sister

If your child asked Santa for a baby brother, ask what they picture doing together. They might want someone to play with, or they might have seen a friend become a big sibling. You can listen to that picture and tell them, “I can see why you’d like that. Santa brings presents, and babies are part of a family.”

An answer about whether your family will have a baby belongs in a private conversation. Keep it as brief as you need to. “I know that’s something you’d like. I love being your parent” is enough to start. For a family that has already shared the news, our Santa letter guide for a new big sibling has wording for that milestone.

“Thank you for telling me about your wish for a little brother. I loved hearing that you’d pick out a book to read together.”

Use a detail that fits what your child said. If they make the wish in front of relatives, you can hear them out there and talk about it together later.

If the Wish Is Make-Believe or the Gift Needs to Wait

What Santa can’t bring depends on why the gift is out of reach. You can be playful about a real reindeer. When the wish is for a phone and your child is too young for one, give the family rule in your own words. “We’re waiting until you’re older for a phone” is an answer they can hear again when the subject comes up in January.

“A real reindeer would take up most of your living room. Dasher is staying with his herd, and he sends you a big Christmas hello.”

If your child wants to fly to the moon, ask if they’d like to look at it through binoculars with you. Let the interest guide you if you want to plan something together. Keep Santa’s reply about the wish itself unless you’ve already decided what will be under the tree.

If the Gift Costs More Than You Plan to Spend

When a child asks Santa for something you can’t give because of the price, keep the spending decision with the grown-ups. “I know you’ve been looking forward to that game system. We aren’t buying one this Christmas. Which games do you most like playing with your friends?” answers the request and gives your child room to tell you why it mattered.

If your child asked Santa for something expensive because a classmate has it, listen for what they’re hoping to share with that friend. You might be able to make time for a game afternoon. If your family is also deciding which gifts come from Santa, see our guide to choosing Santa gifts. For a change to the whole holiday budget, use our guide to explaining fewer presents.

“I loved hearing about the games you and your friends play together. Thank you for telling me what you were hoping for.”

What to Write in the Note You Leave at Home

Skip This Line Say This Instead
“Maybe next Christmas.” “Thank you for telling me what you were hoping for.”
“You’ll get it if you’re extra good.” “I loved hearing how much you care about animals.”
“The elves ran out of money.” “I’m glad you shared your Christmas list with me.”
“Go ask your parents for a baby.” “It sounds like you’ve thought about what it would be like to be a big sibling.”

If the wish involves someone who’s sick or someone your child misses, leave the cheerful workshop explanation out of it. Our guide to Santa letters after a hard year covers what to say in those situations.

How a Letter Can Help When a Child Asks Santa for Something You Can’t Give

Santa’s Magical Kingdom makes personalized letters using details you share about your child. Start with their first name and an interest they talk about all the time. Add something they did this year that made you proud. That might be finishing their first chapter book, even when it took three weeks, or sticking with soccer after a hard first practice.

If They Wished For A Detail You Could Share With Santa
A puppy or pony They draw dogs on every birthday card or look for horses on the way to school.
A baby brother or sister They learned to read a favorite story aloud. Keep private family details at home.
A real reindeer They know all the reindeer names and always look for Rudolph first.
A big gift They draw maps for the games they make up with friends.

If you’re looking for a letter from Santa explaining why he can’t bring a gift, write the explanation yourself and tuck it beside the personalized letter. The short note can answer the exact question. Our letter can celebrate a detail that belongs to your child, giving them something of their own to read aloud or keep.

Choose a printed letter by mail or select email delivery right away, on Christmas Eve, or on Christmas morning from the options shown on the order form.

Our 2026 shipping guide recommends ordering by December 15 for standard shipping or December 20 for express. Check the date shown at checkout. You can see sample letters on the order page.

Personalize Your Child’s Letter From Santa

If They Want to Tell Santa in Person

At Santa’s Magical Kingdom in Eureka, Missouri, families can meet Santa inside Kringle’s General Store nightly from November 20 through December 23, including Thanksgiving.

If your child has been practicing what they’ll say, let them share it. Tell them before you go that they can talk to Santa about anything on their list. We send professional Santa photos by text.

You can make an evening of it with the drive-through lights and hot cocoa from Kringle’s General Store. On Thanksgiving, drive-through admission is $35 per family vehicle, payable in cash as you exit. On the ride home, ask what they liked about seeing Santa. Their answer can give you a detail for the letter.

Frequently Asked Questions

When a Child Asks Santa for Something You Can’t Give, What Should You Say?

Acknowledge what they wanted. “You really wanted a pony. We’re keeping that as a wish this year.” Give them time to respond.

Should I Answer Before Christmas?

Yes, if your child expects the gift. A clear answer gives them time to ask questions before they’re opening presents.

What if My Child Asked Santa for a Puppy?

Say that getting a dog is a decision for the whole family. Tell them what your family has decided for this Christmas.

What if We’re Already Getting a Pet?

Choose a day when an adult can help the animal settle in. Explain how everyone will help.

What if My Child Asked Santa for a Baby Brother?

Say that Santa brings presents and that questions about a baby belong at home. Let your child tell you what they imagined.

Who Explains if My Child Asked Santa for Something Expensive?

Explain the purchase decision yourself. If the answer is final, say so before helping them think of other ideas.

How Do I Decide What Santa Can’t Bring?

Keep family decisions at home. That includes pets, family changes, safety rules, and big purchases.

What if My Child Asks Again After I’ve Answered?

Give the same answer with care. Ask what they’re still wondering about, especially if they think trying harder could change it.

What if They Ask Santa During a Visit?

Let them finish telling Santa. Talk privately afterward so your child can ask what will happen.

What if an Older Sibling Answers First?

Take over the conversation and tell your younger child what the family has decided. Give the older sibling a separate moment to talk through what happened.

When a Child Asks Santa for Something You Can’t Give, What Helps on Christmas Morning?

Sit with your child and name what they’re missing. Give them a moment before you ask whether they’re ready to open something else.

Can I Order a Letter From Santa Explaining Why He Can’t Bring a Gift?

Our letters use details you share to celebrate your child. For exact wording about the gift, add your own note.

What Should I Share if the Wish Feels Too Private?

Pick an everyday detail, like a book they keep rereading or a drawing they put on the fridge. Keep the family conversation private.

Give Your Child a Letter They’ll Want to Keep

When a child asks Santa for something you can’t give, let them hear the answer from you. Then think of something they’d love Santa to know. Maybe they still talk about the day they learned to ride their bike or the joke they told him at Kringle’s. Start there when you create a personalized letter from Santa. Choose how it arrives and give them a message about a part of their year worth remembering.

Open Nov 20 to Jan 3Plan Your Magical Night

Drive through millions of lights every night from 5:30 to 10:30pm. $35 per carload.

Plan Your Visit Call 636-938-5925
Letters from Santa

A personalized letter from the North Pole, written just for your child.

Create a Letter
Train & Wagon Rides

From $18 per person. Book 2+ riders and admission is waived!

Book a Ride ➜

Related Articles

Why Does Santa Wear Red? The Real Story Behind His Famous Suit

Why Does Santa Wear Red? The Real Story Behind His Famous Suit

Santa wears red because generations of artists, publishers, retailers, and advertisers kept showing him that way. Coca-Cola made the look more familiar in the twentieth

When a Child Asks Santa for Something You Can’t Give

On the way home from seeing Santa, your child starts picking names for the puppy they just asked him to bring. When a child asks

Santa Claus Initials Explained The Magic Behind S.C.

Santa Claus Initials Explained: The Magic Behind S.C.

Let’s be real for a second. We all know the guy. Red suit, big belly, questionable chimney-climbing skills, and a serious addiction to cookies. But