Set out milk, a cookie, a carrot for the reindeer, and a short note on Christmas Eve. If you’re deciding what to leave out for Santa while you’re still wrapping presents, four things from the kitchen and a scrap of paper will do. Your child can pick the cookie and write the note while you get the rest of the evening ready.
A missing bite shows Santa stopped by. A reply with your child’s name and a detail they recognize gives them something to read while they’re still standing by the plate. At Santa’s Magical Kingdom, we make personalized Letters from Santa for families who want to plan that surprise ahead of time.
What to Leave Out for Santa When You Have Five Minutes
Start with a plate and a cup from the cupboard. Let your child choose where they go and give each sibling a job if everybody wants to help.
| Put Out | Use What You Have |
| A drink | Pour a little milk, or use water or a drink your family already keeps on hand. |
| A treat | Choose a chocolate chip cookie, a piece of shortbread, or a clementine. |
| A reindeer snack | Put a carrot on the plate or in a small dish beside it. |
| A note | Fold a handwritten thank-you or set a signed drawing beside the cup. |
Cookies for Santa can come from the bakery box you opened after dinner. If two children want to pick, give them one cookie each and let them tell you why theirs made the plate. When there’s a food allergy in the house, use a treat your family already knows is suitable. A drawing of a cookie works, too, if your child would rather keep the whole setup on paper.
Why Santa Gets Milk and Cookies
Milk and cookies for Santa became a familiar American Christmas Eve tradition, but the exact start is hard to pin down. NPR’s reporting, published by KPBS, traces the pairing to an American Christmas story from the 1870s. It also recounts an 1896 letter to St. Nicholas magazine in which a child describes choosing the snack with her brother.
HISTORY dates the custom’s wider popularity to the Great Depression and connects it with teaching children generosity. It also describes a folklore theory about children leaving food for Odin’s horse during Yule. At home, the plate makes the idea easy to understand. Your child gets to welcome a visitor with something they chose themselves.
Give the Reindeer Their Own Snack
If your child asks what to leave out for reindeer, put a carrot beside Santa’s cookie. A separate little dish lets a younger sibling help, even if an older child is doing the writing. Keep the carrot indoors so you can set up the whole plate before bed.
If the lawn is part of your family’s tradition, skip glitter. The RSPCA’s reindeer food guide warns that it can harm garden wildlife. Our guide to Santa letters and reindeer food has ideas for families who want to keep the outdoor part of the ritual.
Give Your Child One Line to Start the Note
A note to Santa can be a drawing, a thank-you, or one detail about why your child picked that particular cookie. Here are three starting lines. Read one aloud and let your child change it.
- Ages 2 to 4. “Dear Santa, I picked this carrot for your reindeer.” Write down their words and leave space for a drawing.
- Ages 5 to 7. “Dear Santa, I saved you the biggest cookie. Please say hi to the reindeer.” Let your child sign it or add their own reason for picking the treat.
- Ages 8 and Up. “Dear Santa, I learned to ride my bike this year. What did you like doing when you were my age?” Invite your child to swap in something they’re proud of and a question of their own.
Set the note beside the plate so the paper stays dry. If you’re ordering a reply ahead of time, pick a detail you already know your child would recognize, such as the bike they finally learned to ride. You can use the letter alongside the plate even if they decide to write about something else at bedtime.
Snacks Families Leave in Other Countries
If your child wonders what kids leave for Santa around the world, the answer depends on the household and who’s supposed to visit. These are examples of family customs, including one that takes place before Christmas Eve.
| Place | A Treat Families May Leave |
| United Kingdom | A mince pie for Father Christmas, sometimes with sherry |
| Sweden | Rice porridge for Jultomte |
| The Netherlands | A carrot in a shoe for Sinterklaas’s horse on the evening of December 5 |
| Chile | Pan de pascua, a Christmas fruitcake |
NPR’s holiday food reporting describes the British, Swedish, and Chilean examples. The St. Nicholas Center records the shoe custom in a family’s account. Our guide to Santa Claus around the world tells the stories behind the different gift-bringers.
Bring the Cookie Idea Home From Santa’s Magical Kingdom
If your family is still debating what to leave out for Santa, let your child pick a cookie after a night at Santa’s Magical Kingdom. Our drive-through light show is at Jellystone Park in Eureka, Missouri, next to Six Flags. The snack shack serves fresh chocolate chip cookies and hot cocoa, so your child can try a treat and decide what belongs on the plate at home.
In 2026, the lights open at 5:30 p.m. on Thanksgiving night, November 26, and run from 5:30 to 10:30 p.m. on Christmas Eve. On December 24, admission is $35 per family vehicle, payable in cash as you exit. Check drive-through hours and admission before heading out.
If your child wants to tell Santa what they’re leaving him, plan that visit by December 23. Santa meets families for professional photos inside Kringle’s General Store through that date. After your last outing on Christmas Eve, let your child set out the cookie, carrot, and note while you pour the drink.
What to Leave Out for Santa if You Want a Morning Surprise
A crumb beside the cup or a carrot with the tip snapped off is enough for your child to notice something has changed. Keep the plate in the spot they chose. That’s where they’ll look first.
- Leave a bite missing from the cookie your child picked.
- Put the cup back where they left it.
- If your family uses a Santa key, return it to its usual place.
- Set a folded reply beside the plate with your child’s name facing up.
If you need to keep the plate away from a pet, put the food in a room the pet can’t enter. You can leave the paper reply in your child’s chosen spot for the morning.
Order a Personalized Reply for Christmas Morning
Our Letters from Santa service lets you build the reply around details your child will recognize. Enter their first name, share an interest or something they did this year that made you proud, and choose how Santa sounds. A child who spent all fall practicing a cartwheel can get a letter that mentions gymnastics. You can choose a letter design and include a Christmas wish if you want to share one.
Choose a mailed letter if you’d like an envelope ready to set out with the plate. For 2026, order by December 15 if you’re choosing standard mail. Our shipping guidance lists December 20 for express. Check the options for your date at checkout. For email, select Christmas morning to read it together that day, or choose an earlier available date if you want time to print it before bedtime.
You can see sample designs on the order page. The order form explains how we handle your child’s information. For more ways to leave the reply, see our Christmas morning letter guide.
Create a Personalized Letter From Santa
Questions Parents Ask About Santa’s Plate
What Goes on Santa’s Plate?
If you’re wondering what to leave out for Santa, start with a cookie, a drink, a carrot, and a note.
Why Do Families Leave Milk and Cookies for Santa?
The snack welcomes Santa. American references go back to the 1800s, and HISTORY dates the custom’s wider popularity to the 1930s.
What If We Didn’t Bake?
Store-bought cookies for Santa work fine. A muffin or a piece of fruit works, too.
What Goes in the Reindeer Dish?
If you’re deciding what to leave out for reindeer, a carrot in a dish indoors is enough. For an outdoor ritual, keep glitter off the lawn.
What Should My Child Write?
A note to Santa can thank him, explain who picked the treat, or ask a question. Children who are still learning to write can dictate or draw.
What About Other Countries?
Examples of what kids leave for Santa around the world include mince pies in the United Kingdom and rice porridge for Jultomte in Sweden.
When Does the Plate Go Out?
Once you’ve decided what to leave out for Santa, set the plate after your last outing. Let your child pour the drink just before bed.
Where Can We Put the Plate?
Use a table near the tree or another spot your child can find easily in the morning. Ask them to pick it before bedtime.
What About Food Allergies?
Choose a treat you already know suits your household. Your child can also draw the snack and leave the picture with their thank-you.
What If We Have a Dog?
Keep chocolate chip cookies out of your dog’s reach. Use a room with a closed door, or leave just the note.
Should Santa Finish the Cookie?
One bite and a few crumbs give your child something to spot. You can leave the other cookie whole if they set out two.
Is Santa at Kringle’s on Christmas Eve?
Santa’s last photo night at Kringle’s is December 23. The drive-through lights are open on Christmas Eve, so you can still visit before setting out the plate.
Can I Print Santa’s Reply Early?
Choose an earlier available email date when you order so you have time to print Santa’s reply before setting it out.
Give Santa Something to Write Back About
When you’re deciding what to leave out for Santa, give your child the last word on the cookie and the note. Then order Santa’s reply for your child and build it around a detail they’ll recognize when they see their name beside the plate on Christmas morning.

